|The World Trade Organization ruled Wednesday that US restrictions on overseas-based Internet gambling operations violate ‘Free’ Trade laws.
The ruling has huge repurcussions, and the Bush administration vowed an immediate appeal. The reaction from the US was hysterical, in both meanings of the word. “It’s appalling,” said Representative Bob Goodlatte, a Virginia Republican. “It cannot be allowed to stand that another nation can impose its values on the U.S. and make it a trade issue.”
If course, imposing US and Western values on other nations is precisely what ‘free’ trade does. And the whole principle of the ‘free’ trade deals brokered by corporatist interests behind closed doors is to subvert and subordinate national laws to the ‘broader’ interests of international trade (read: the interests of multinational corporations and the governments they finance). Under such agreements domestic social and environmental laws can be overturned as a ‘restriction on trade’, to the extent they exceed the lowest standards in any of the signatory countries to the agreement. Social laws include not only labour laws, but any laws that impede the unregulated flow of goods and services across borders, including anti-gambling laws.
In principle, therefore, the US hasn’t got a leg to stand on. But in law, of course, money buys the best lawyers and allows rich murderers and criminals to go free, while the poor, even if innocent and in the right, usually lose. And if money doesn’t buy off the WTO, the US has already signaled that it will consider itself above the law, and ignore it. Several members of Congress said they would rather have an international trade war or withdraw from future rounds of the World Trade Organization than have American social policy dictated from abroad.
The Bush regime, which has promised its corporatist backers to pursue ‘free’ trade, cannot break its old unilateralist habits when things don’t go its way. Bush has yet to learn that ‘my way or the highway’ is not a negotiation strategy. “The U.S. says it wants open competition,” said Sir Ronald Sanders, Antigua’s foreign affairs representative. “But it only wants free trade when it suits the U.S.”
The unresolved question is whether international Internet service businesses can be regulated at all. But that’s a ‘World of Ends‘ issue. Right now, to the American trade imperialists and anti-gambling lobbies, it’s an ‘End of the World’ issue. Expect much moaning and wringing of hands.
March 26, 2004
Every once in awhile I find an article that simply speaks for itself. It cannot be improved by summarizing, annotating, digesting or synthesizing. The Empire Strikes Out, by Kenny Ausubel in Orion Magazine Online, is one such article. Here it is:
NATURE BATS LAST
For all the chatter about the Age of Information, we really seem to be entering the Age of Biology. We didn’t invent nature. Nature invented us. Nature bats last, as the saying goes and, more importantly, it’s her playing field. We would do well to learn at least some of the ground rules.
The great ecological play takes place in a food web that makes no waste, powered by a solar economy that neither mines the past nor mortgages the future. Some of its guiding principles are diversity, kinship, symbiosis, reciprocity and community. It’s alive. It’s intelligent. It’s connected. It’s all relatives.
One of the beauties of biology is that its facts can become our metaphors. These underlying codes may also serve as inspiring parables for how as human beings we might organize a more just, humane, and authentically sustainable society.
Life is intimacy interconnected. As a culture we’ve made a basic systems error to believe that we exist somehow separate from nature, or from one another. That illusion could prove fatal at this momentous cusp, this time at which our turbo-charged technologies and overwhelming numbers have given us, for the first time in history, the capacity to blow it on a planetary scale.
Our globalized corporate empire menaces the future of the entire biosphere. Empires are castles made of sand: They always crumble, they always fade away. But by the time this empire strikes out, the biological game could be all but over. Corporate globalization is killing off its host — and ours. Gary Larsen once did a cartoon in which a ship is sinking, and a pack of dogs crowded into a lifeboat are watching it go down. The lead dog says to the others, “OK — all those in favor of eating all the food all at once, raise your paws.” That’s economic globalization in a nutshell.
The real-world situation that is spontaneously combusting today is a perfect storm of extreme environmental degradation and rolling infrastructure collapse. It is by no means the first time this has happened. Previous civilizations have slid into ruin through self-induced environmental catastrophe, but in the past the damage has always been localized.
But there’s more to it. They had foolish leaders…who embroiled them in destabilizing wars and didn’t pay attention to problems at home.
HISTORY LESSON: DISINTEGRATION OCCURS SUDDENLY, JUST AFTER THE PEAK
As Jared Diamond pointed out in “Guns, Germs, and Steel,” these societies met their demise by cutting down forests, eroding topsoil and building burgeoning cities in dry areas that eventually ran short of water. Sometimes hastened by sudden climate change, the ensuing disintegration occurred suddenly — in a matter of a decade or two after a society reached its peak of population, wealth and power. Because that pinnacle also marked maximum resource consumption and waste production, it produced unsupportable environmental impacts.
But there’s more to it, Diamond says. “They had foolish leaders…who embroiled them in destabilizing wars and didn’t pay attention to problems at home. They were overwhelmed by desperate immigrants, as one society after another collapsed, sending floods of economic refugees to tax the resources of the societies that weren’t collapsing.”
When Diamond studied the ecological downfall of Mexico’s ancient Mayan civilization, he determined that the final strand in its unravelling was a crisis of political leadership. “Their [leaders] attention was evidently focused on the short-term concerns of enriching themselves, waging wars, erecting monuments, competing with one another, and extracting enough food from the peasants to support all these activities.” Sound familiar, fellow peasants?
Today we’re going mano a mano with the whole biosphere, and she’s responding with her own form of deregulation. The planet is reeling from record-smashing temperatures, violent storms, long-term droughts, hundred-year floods, unstoppable fires, massive insect infestations, migrating disease patterns, rising seas, and a level of species extinctions not seen in 65 million years. Twelve-thousand people died in France this summer from record-setting heat. In Phoenix, Arizona, people’s flip-flops melted on the pavement. One woman who tripped and fell face-first on the sidewalk was rushed to a burn unit. And global warming is just getting going.
Last year, the White House pressured the EPA to hit the delete key in its state-of-the-environment report regarding the forty-weight connection between global warming and the burning of fossil fuels. The US political class says we need more scientific study while they march us backwards into the 21st century dragging sacks of coal behind them. But the science is unequivocal: It’s no longer a matter of connecting the dots. It’s a matter of connecting the elephants in the room.
Global warming means more and bigger storms, and one of the most striking images from the relatively mild Hurricane Miserabel was the battered mall of the Washington Monument. A large stand of flagpoles forlornly flew the stars and stripes, shredded to tatters by the violent weather. As the great urban farmer Michael Abelman said, “After all, what good is a country and a flag if there is no more fertile soil, no ancient forests, no clean water, no pure food? If you really love your country, protect and restore some wildness. Support local agriculture. Plant a garden. Those who work to protect and restore these things are the real patriots.”
THE BREEDING GROUNDS FOR TERRORISM HAVE THE WORST ENVIRONMENTAL DEVASTATION AND POVERTY
In truth, the US political class is clueless. Its only plan is to eat all the food all at once. Although the empire may seem awesomely powerful, it’s coming apart at the seams.
But what is also true here and around the world is that people are stepping up with real solutions. There’s a new superpower: Global popular movements. They are growing from the bottom up, taking back control over our lives, our communities, our economies and our cultures. People are again starting to assume responsibility for the lands, the waters, the forests, and the global commons we all share.
People worldwide are rejecting the deification of the market over environmental and human rights. As Amory Lovins has said, “Markets make a great servant but a bad master and a worse religion… And a society that tries to substitute markets for politics, ethics, or faith is seriously adrift.”
There are brilliant scientific and social innovators among us who’ve been patiently incubating the seeds of successful local, regional, and even societal plans for the transformation to a sustainable civilization. An alternative globalization movement of unprecedented proportions is taking shape, weaving a green web of innovative models grounded in true biotechnologies and social equity.
This new world is being born right now before our eyes. It mimics the decentralized intelligence of living systems, the innate democracy of life. It’s founded in the recognition that the first homeland security comes from environmental security. Our civilization’s out-of-body experience is screeching to a halt as we awaken to our absolute dependence on natural life-support systems and our interdependence with all life. Cleaning up the environment will happen only when we clean up politics and reclaim our government.
In a world where half the people live on $2 a day or less, we can have no peace. The world’s most dangerous political hot spots and breeding grounds for terrorism are exactly the same places with the worst environmental devastation and poverty. Go figure.
DEMOCRACY IS NOT A SPECTATOR SPORT
We’re entering into unknown territory. There will be little to hold onto. It could be a time of unimaginable suffering and loss. But it will also be a renaissance of flourishing creativity and deep healing. The regenerative capacity of nature is powerful beyond our imagination. And the boundless nobility of the human soul is arising everywhere in waves of caring and kindness. Our social security is being woven in community, as people gather to mend our shredded social fabric and solve problems together. There is as much cause for hope as for horror. And we know we must prevail.
We can start by attending to our worst wounds. In very practical terms, the solution is to invest in our problems. We need a Green New Deal, a massive global investment in repairing the environment, transforming our infrastructures, and restoring people. The measure of any solution is whether it solves for pattern by resolving multiple problems in one fell swoop.
What’s called for is strong government leadership to reboot the system. We need an immediate global Marshall plan of clean, renewable energy, and the re-design and rebuilding of our decaying infrastructures and clotted transportation systems. We can jump-start a permanent transition to an ecological agriculture that produces healthy, nutritious food in regionalized foodsheds — restores the land, air and water — and revives rural economies thriving with small and medium-sized farms. We need a just legal system that puts human and environmental rights above corporate rights. All these programs will yield dramatically positive results — environmentally, economically, socially and spiritually. And all of it is attainable.
In great measure we already know what to do, in practical terms, to realize this vision. The vexing bottleneck we face is political, not technological. As the Italian dictator Benito Mussolini, known as The Father of Fascism, said in a refreshing moment of candor, “Fascism should more properly be called corporatism, since it is the merger of state and corporate power.” As the whole world becomes a company town, democracy is in peril of becoming a phantom limb, severed from the body politic while we imagine it’s still attached. Cleaning up the environment will happen when we clean up politics and reclaim our government. Democracy is not a spectator sport. Voting is not something we can do just every two or four years. We need to vote every day with our lives.
The coming environmental blowback and social dislocation could just as easily swing us toward martial law and totalitarian rule. If we don’t change direction, we will end up where we’re heading.
Thanks to Jeff Gold of the Ontario Green Party for the link.