![]() James Surowiecki, the financial reporter for The New Yorker, has a new book out called The Wisdom of Crowds. It is essentially about decision-making, and the two most fatal (and ironically, almost opposite) judgement errors we make when making decisions:
The consequences of both types of flawed decision-making can be catastrophic, and constitute what I have called the cost of not knowing. I have cited Surowiecki before in this blog, and I have enormous respect for his sharp, challenging mind. His is no conventional wisdom — he’s imaginative, brilliantly logical and profoundly skeptical. Groupthink can be prevented, he says, by ensuring the group has intellectual diversity, independence (from each other) and is neither too centralized nor too decentralized. A group with these qualities is inherently more knowledgeable and its judgement more sophisticated, informed and reliable than any CEO or ‘subject matter expert’ that business, with its cult of leadership, tends to rely on for making critical decisions. The greatest knowledge failures in recent history are preventative failures, sins of omission — notably 9/11, SARS, bird flu, BSE, the Great Blackout of ’03, Enron and other corporate rip-offs, and, in Canada, the Walkerton e coli deaths, not to mention many murders and other crimes. To what extent did our failure to prevent such disasters result from simply not having critical information, and to what extent were these failures aggravated by groupthink or individual arrogance? Was groupthink on a very large scale behind the dot com bubble, and is it happening again now? And is the dearth of genuine innovation in large organizations also partly attributable to these judgement errors? Surowiecki tackles these questions thoroughly and provocatively, and proffers some steps we can take to employ the wisdom of crowds (or, more precisely, substantial, informed, well-designed decision-making and decision-influencing groups) to prevent groupthink or arrogance from producing knowledge failures. But Surowiecki’s most unsetlling lesson is that much of the time, these failures arise not (or at least not just) because we don’t know, but because we don’t want to know, or don’t care to know. Painting above is Van Gogh’s ‘Pollard Birches’. Pollarding is the process of harvestiing the tops off trees without killing the tree, so that they grow back. Its earliest practitioners gave me my surname. |
Navigation
Collapsniks
Albert Bates (US)
Andrew Nikiforuk (CA)
Brutus (US)
Carolyn Baker (US)*
Catherine Ingram (US)
Chris Hedges (US)
Dahr Jamail (US)
Dean Spillane-Walker (US)*
Derrick Jensen (US)
Dougald & Paul (IE/SE)*
Gail Tverberg (US)
Guy McPherson (US)
Honest Sorcerer
Janaia & Robin (US)*
Jem Bendell (UK)
Mari Werner
Michael Dowd (US)*
Nate Hagens (US)
Paul Heft (US)*
Post Carbon Inst. (US)
Resilience (US)
Richard Heinberg (US)
Robert Jensen (US)
Roy Scranton (US)
Sam Mitchell (US)
Tim Watkins (UK)
Umair Haque (UK)
William Rees (CA)
XrayMike (AU)
Radical Non-Duality
Essential Reading
Archive by Category
My Bio, Contact Info, Signature Posts
About the Author (2023)
My Circles
E-mail me
--- My Best 200 Posts, 2003-22 by category, from newest to oldest ---
Collapse Watch:
Hope — On the Balance of Probabilities
The Caste War for the Dregs
Recuperation, Accommodation, Resilience
How Do We Teach the Critical Skills
Collapse Not Apocalypse
Effective Activism
'Making Sense of the World' Reading List
Notes From the Rising Dark
What is Exponential Decay
Collapse: Slowly Then Suddenly
Slouching Towards Bethlehem
Making Sense of Who We Are
What Would Net-Zero Emissions Look Like?
Post Collapse with Michael Dowd (video)
Why Economic Collapse Will Precede Climate Collapse
Being Adaptable: A Reminder List
A Culture of Fear
What Will It Take?
A Future Without Us
Dean Walker Interview (video)
The Mushroom at the End of the World
What Would It Take To Live Sustainably?
The New Political Map (Poster)
Beyond Belief
Complexity and Collapse
Requiem for a Species
Civilization Disease
What a Desolated Earth Looks Like
If We Had a Better Story...
Giving Up on Environmentalism
The Hard Part is Finding People Who Care
Going Vegan
The Dark & Gathering Sameness of the World
The End of Philosophy
A Short History of Progress
The Boiling Frog
Our Culture / Ourselves:
A CoVid-19 Recap
What It Means to be Human
A Culture Built on Wrong Models
Understanding Conservatives
Our Unique Capacity for Hatred
Not Meant to Govern Each Other
The Humanist Trap
Credulous
Amazing What People Get Used To
My Reluctant Misanthropy
The Dawn of Everything
Species Shame
Why Misinformation Doesn't Work
The Lab-Leak Hypothesis
The Right to Die
CoVid-19: Go for Zero
Pollard's Laws
On Caste
The Process of Self-Organization
The Tragic Spread of Misinformation
A Better Way to Work
The Needs of the Moment
Ask Yourself This
What to Believe Now?
Rogue Primate
Conversation & Silence
The Language of Our Eyes
True Story
May I Ask a Question?
Cultural Acedia: When We Can No Longer Care
Useless Advice
Several Short Sentences About Learning
Why I Don't Want to Hear Your Story
A Harvest of Myths
The Qualities of a Great Story
The Trouble With Stories
A Model of Identity & Community
Not Ready to Do What's Needed
A Culture of Dependence
So What's Next
Ten Things to Do When You're Feeling Hopeless
No Use to the World Broken
Living in Another World
Does Language Restrict What We Can Think?
The Value of Conversation Manifesto Nobody Knows Anything
If I Only Had 37 Days
The Only Life We Know
A Long Way Down
No Noble Savages
Figments of Reality
Too Far Ahead
Learning From Nature
The Rogue Animal
How the World Really Works:
Making Sense of Scents
An Age of Wonder
The Truth About Ukraine
Navigating Complexity
The Supply Chain Problem
The Promise of Dialogue
Too Dumb to Take Care of Ourselves
Extinction Capitalism
Homeless
Republicans Slide Into Fascism
All the Things I Was Wrong About
Several Short Sentences About Sharks
How Change Happens
What's the Best Possible Outcome?
The Perpetual Growth Machine
We Make Zero
How Long We've Been Around (graphic)
If You Wanted to Sabotage the Elections
Collective Intelligence & Complexity
Ten Things I Wish I'd Learned Earlier
The Problem With Systems
Against Hope (Video)
The Admission of Necessary Ignorance
Several Short Sentences About Jellyfish
Loren Eiseley, in Verse
A Synopsis of 'Finding the Sweet Spot'
Learning from Indigenous Cultures
The Gift Economy
The Job of the Media
The Wal-Mart Dilemma
The Illusion of the Separate Self, and Free Will:
No Free Will, No Freedom
The Other Side of 'No Me'
This Body Takes Me For a Walk
The Only One Who Really Knew Me
No Free Will — Fightin' Words
The Paradox of the Self
A Radical Non-Duality FAQ
What We Think We Know
Bark Bark Bark Bark Bark Bark Bark
Healing From Ourselves
The Entanglement Hypothesis
Nothing Needs to Happen
Nothing to Say About This
What I Wanted to Believe
A Continuous Reassemblage of Meaning
No Choice But to Misbehave
What's Apparently Happening
A Different Kind of Animal
Happy Now?
This Creature
Did Early Humans Have Selves?
Nothing On Offer Here
Even Simpler and More Hopeless Than That
Glimpses
How Our Bodies Sense the World
Fragments
What Happens in Vagus
We Have No Choice
Never Comfortable in the Skin of Self
Letting Go of the Story of Me
All There Is, Is This
A Theory of No Mind
Creative Works:
Mindful Wanderings (Reflections) (Archive)
A Prayer to No One
Frogs' Hollow (Short Story)
We Do What We Do (Poem)
Negative Assertions (Poem)
Reminder (Short Story)
A Canadian Sorry (Satire)
Under No Illusions (Short Story)
The Ever-Stranger (Poem)
The Fortune Teller (Short Story)
Non-Duality Dude (Play)
Your Self: An Owner's Manual (Satire)
All the Things I Thought I Knew (Short Story)
On the Shoulders of Giants (Short Story)
Improv (Poem)
Calling the Cage Freedom (Short Story)
Rune (Poem)
Only This (Poem)
The Other Extinction (Short Story)
Invisible (Poem)
Disruption (Short Story)
A Thought-Less Experiment (Poem)
Speaking Grosbeak (Short Story)
The Only Way There (Short Story)
The Wild Man (Short Story)
Flywheel (Short Story)
The Opposite of Presence (Satire)
How to Make Love Last (Poem)
The Horses' Bodies (Poem)
Enough (Lament)
Distracted (Short Story)
Worse, Still (Poem)
Conjurer (Satire)
A Conversation (Short Story)
Farewell to Albion (Poem)
My Other Sites
Hope you don’t mind me cluttering up your comments section, but EO Wilson put it quite well: “The ability of the brain to generate novel scenarios and settle on the most effective among them is called creativity. The persistent production of scenarios lacking reality and survival value is called insanity”So maybe we’re trying to balance the two here? Groupthink stifles creativity, but without groupthink, (and maybe with a little authority) creativity becomes insanity.
I loved Edward O Wilson’s book Consilience: The Unity of Knowledge. But I’m very interested in James Surowiecki’s book. I think they might be a great companion for one another.Consilience was written in what I call a quiet time, when the world seemed to be progressing toward commonality. Sadly, the US war on terror, which grew to include Iraq, seems to refute Wilson’s vision that the world will arrive at conscilience. Surowiecki, on the other hand, writes with a post 9/11 experience.Reading your review, I was reminded of a quote from Wilson’s thoughtful and astute book that ties in well with your thoughts:”Thanks to science and technology, access to factual knowledge of all kinds is rising exponentially while dropping in unit cost. It is destined to become global and democratic. Soon it will be available everywhere on television and computer screens. What then? The answer is clear: synthesis. We are drowning in information, while starving for wisdom. The world henceforth will be run by synthesizers, people able to put together the right information at the right time, think critically about it, and make important choices wisely.”If there is something lacking right now, and maybe Wilson can be credited for seeing this need back in 2000, it is the need for synthesizers who can analyze all the information and “make important choices wisely.” I have more quotes from Consilience in an August 28 post of last year if you are interested– http://blogs.salon.com/0002090/2003/08/28.htmlThanks for the review, Dave.
Piers: I think there’s a difference between groupthink (a herd mentality) and wild idealism — speaking as someone prone to both. I think groupthink is often a sign of ignorance or intellectual lazyness. What roots innovation in reality (where it belongs if it is to be of any value) is not that it can be successfully sold or marketed to lots of people, but that the idea stemmed from a known customer need in the first place. The difference between a wild and crazy product idea and a wildly successful one, is that the inventor of the latter listened carefully to someone other than himself.Michael: I’ve read Consilience and found it had a few brilliant turns of phrase but otherwise needed ‘more matter and less art’, as Shakespeare said. It’s interesting — I made a presentation to a conference of journalists a few years ago on The Future of The Media, and I said exactly what Wilson does: The media need to commoditize the facts and make them available to everyone free, and demonstrate their value (and get their revenue) by hiring subject matter experts to do analysis, investigative reporting, ground-breaking research, intelligence-gathering and other ‘synthesis’ activities, based on these facts, to tell us ‘what it all means’. At the time they said ‘that’s not our job’.
I find it fascinating that the media believed it was not their job to commoditize the information. I think of blogging and often think that there is more similation and analyzing (synthesis activities) going on between bloggers, which has progressively widened its reach from the mere blog community to the general public to the media community, which initially discredited it. Thanks for the information regarding Consilience.
Greetings from a fellow Pollard. Love your weblog, thanks!